Whisky Blending Hose Snakepit Risk Reduction

A whisky producer engaged IDEA to reduce the safety and operational risks created by increasingly complex hose routing within a blending facility. IDEA worked with operators to establish the true routing requirements through Route Matrix Workshops, evaluated flow plates, valve matrices and hybrid solutions, and developed the preferred concept through detailed engineering. The objective was to retain the flexibility required for whisky blending operations while reducing manual hose handling, trip hazards, routing complexity and the potential for operator error.

At a glance

  • Sector: Distilled Spirits
  • Scope: Route Matrix Workshops, optioneering and detailed engineering
  • Disciplines: Process engineering and multidisciplinary design
  • Outcome: An engineered routing solution designed to reduce hose handling, trip hazards and misrouting potential while retaining operational flexibility

Client Overview

The client operates a whisky blending facility requiring flexible transfer routes between multiple vessels, storage areas and downstream operations.

Whisky blending and bulk spirit handling depend on the ability to move product safely between different sources and destinations. Different recipes, batch sizes, tank availability, cleaning requirements and production schedules can all affect which transfer routes are required.

Flexible hoses had historically provided a practical way of accommodating these changing requirements. However, as the facility developed and additional routes were introduced, the hose network became increasingly complex.

The challenge: reducing hose routing risk without losing flexibility

The challenge was to replace an increasingly congested hose routing arrangement with a safer and more controlled system without restricting the flexibility required by blending operations.

Over time, multiple overlapping hose routes had created what is commonly referred to as a hose "snakepit".

The principal challenges included:

  • Manual handling of heavy and awkward hoses during routine transfers.
  • Trip and fall hazards where hoses crossed or congested operational areas.
  • Increased routing complexity as the number of sources and destinations grew.
  • Greater potential for incorrect connections or product misrouting.
  • Restricted access and poorer housekeeping around vessels and equipment.
  • The need to maintain sufficient flexibility for different products, batches, cleaning activities and abnormal operating scenarios.

IDEA's role

IDEA applied an operator-led engineering approach, first establishing how the facility actually needed to operate before developing and comparing alternative routing solutions.

IDEA began by facilitating structured Route Matrix Workshops with operators and relevant stakeholders.

These workshops established:

  • Required source-to-destination transfer routes.
  • Frequency of each transfer.
  • Normal operating requirements.
  • Less frequent and exceptional routes.
  • Cleaning and changeover requirements.
  • Tank outage and maintenance scenarios.
  • Sampling requirements.
  • Space, access and isolation constraints.
  • Existing operational pain points

From route matrix to engineered options

The information was converted into a structured route matrix, creating a controlled definition of what needed to connect to what.

This provided the design basis for subsequent optioneering and reduced reliance on assumptions or informal operational knowledge.

IDEA then evaluated engineered alternatives including:

  • Flow plates, providing controlled connection points while retaining some flexibility.
  • Valve matrices, using fixed pipework and valves to establish different transfer routes.
  • Hybrid solutions, combining fixed routing for frequently used transfers with controlled flexibility for less common requirements.

What we delivered

IDEA developed the project from operational route definition through optioneering and into detailed engineering for the preferred routing solution.

Options were assessed against safety, ergonomics, operability, human factors, maintainability, CAPEX, OPEX, cleanability, contamination risk and brownfield installation requirements.

The scope included:

  • Operator and stakeholder Route Matrix Workshops.
  • Development of a documented source-to-destination route matrix.
  • Assessment of route frequency and operational criticality.
  • Identification of normal, abnormal and maintenance routing requirements.
  • Optioneering of flow plate, valve matrix and hybrid configurations.
  • Evaluation against safety, human factors, operability, maintainability and whole-life considerations.
  • Selection and development of the preferred engineered routing concept.
  • Arrangement and equipment layout development.
  • Definition of tie-in points with existing systems.
  • Safe access and maintenance considerations.
  • Development or updating of PFDs and P&IDs where applicable.
  • Line lists, valve schedules and equipment tagging information.
  • Operating logic and route selection requirements.
  • Engineering input to commissioning and handover.

Results and outcome

The project provided the client with a structured engineered solution for simplifying whisky transfer routing while reducing the principal safety and human-factor risks associated with extensive hose handling.

Operator input remained central throughout the design so that the proposed system reflected how the facility worked in practice.

The proposed solution was designed to:

  • Reduce routine manual handling of heavy hoses.
  • Remove or reduce hoses crossing operational and access areas.
  • Reduce trip hazards and congestion.
  • Simplify route selection for operators.
  • Reduce the potential for incorrect routing and product transfer.
  • Improve housekeeping and equipment access.
  • Maintain the flexibility required for different blending and transfer scenarios.
  • Provide a controlled engineering basis for future routing requirements.

Why IDEA for whisky blending routing projects

IDEA combines process engineering, operator engagement and multidisciplinary design to develop routing solutions that balance safety, flexibility, operability and practical brownfield implementation.

By starting with the route matrix rather than a predetermined technology, the project allowed the preferred solution to be selected around the client's actual operational requirements.

Our approach includes:

  • Experience of whisky blending and bulk spirit handling operations.
  • Structured Route Matrix Workshops involving the people who operate the system.
  • Vendor-independent optioneering before selecting a preferred technology.
  • Consideration of human factors alongside conventional engineering requirements.
  • Practical design for brownfield and live operational environments.
  • Multidisciplinary capability to progress concepts into detailed, buildable solutions.

Frequently Asked Questions

A Route Matrix Workshop is a structured review with operators and other stakeholders to establish which process sources need to connect to which destinations, how frequently each route is used and what operational constraints apply. The resulting route matrix provides a documented design basis for evaluating and engineering the routing system.

Hose routing systems often become more complex gradually as vessels, processes and transfer requirements are added over time. Individual additions may appear manageable, but collectively they can create congestion, additional manual handling and increasingly complicated routing decisions.

An engineered alternative should be considered where hoses require significant manual handling, regularly cross access routes, create congestion, or where increasing routing complexity raises concerns about incorrect connections or product misrouting.

A flow plate provides defined connection points through which operators establish required routes, normally retaining some manual connection activity. A valve matrix uses fixed pipework and valves to establish alternative routes, reducing the need for physical hose movement. The appropriate solution depends on the number, frequency and complexity of the required transfer routes.

No. The appropriate solution depends on operational requirements. High-frequency routes may justify permanent fixed routing, while rarely used routes may require greater flexibility. A structured route matrix and optioneering process allows flow plates, valve matrices and hybrid arrangements to be assessed objectively.

CONTACT US

Dealing with a hose snakepit or increasingly complex transfer routes?

 IDEA can work with your operations and engineering teams to establish the real routing requirement, evaluate alternative solutions and develop an engineered system that retains the flexibility your operation needs while reducing unnecessary risk.

Subscribe

* indicates required